top of page

How the Subconscious is Transformed in the Indo-European Tradition

​

All Indo-European societies have myths that involve a sequence of events that accumulate the subconscious. Why this is important is explained in an earlier article: Shamanism and Sejd and the Indo-European Tradition, part III.

Here I will give examples of how the transformation occurs through funeral rituals, other rituals, and examples from mythological material.

The “subconscious” and how we can see it from an older perspective

​

Bonnard: Greek Way of Life:

Since “the subconscious” is a psychological term that comes mainly from modern times (Freud, Jung, etc.), we cannot expect that the Indo-Europeans had a directly corresponding concept. However, we can look at functionally similar ideas in the different Indo-European traditions (Vedic, Greek, Celtic, Germanic, etc.) and how these forces were transformed.

​

In Greek mythology, we can see how, through myth, man takes hold of situations and summons his power with all his senses to overcome the forces of nature. In the stories of Odysseus, we can understand this in his challenges, encountering different opponents and monsters.

​

I quote Bonnard:

"In the forbidden area, the blind world of nature, people allow themselves to be lured by creatures with double forms. They then lose their awareness of their natural world. They lose their quality as people in a living society. 

If they do not lose it, it is entirely due to one man, one human being: Odysseus. He is not depicted as a hero here but as an ordinary human being throughout. His expression is completely connected to the battles he has fought and the experiences he has gained. He is portrayed as a human being through the relationships he has with society; the love for the earth, his wife and son but also the love for creation in work and action.

​

Odysseus is a human being who can defeat the demons of the sea by defeating all the resources of his head, his heart and his hands at the same time. Then he can return to his country."

End of quote

​

The description makes me think. In the Indo-European tradition and its myths, our struggle for survival in a nature that includes both wild, mad animals, as well as supernatural monsters, may represent our way of working to overcome monstrous forces within us – in the subconscious. It seems clear to me that through myth we learn to handle insurmountable processes. These processes include both fantasies and reality. In order to create a sense of normality and a clarity in overcoming the “ghosts” within us, a moral way of acting is presented.

​

It is this process that I think is important. It has a significance because in understanding insurmountable “problems” in reality, we can rely on “principles” that permeate both the conscious and the subconscious.

​

Many who have described the Greek way of life during antiquity have regarded it as primitive.

I believe that they have started from a “modern” perspective and have not really understood the whole of the myths meaning from a more holistic perspective.

In this example of Odysseus, I see that there is a combined will that encompasses body and psyche in a fundamentally useful way.

​

I think that from a modern perspective we have lost the ability to “experience” this perspective.

Funeral rituals in the Indo-European tradition respect and emphasize how the subconscious understanding of culture, which includes knowledge, must be passed on to the next generation.

​

Anders Kaliff and Terje Östigård have, in the book: “Cremation and Cosmology – A Comparative Archaeological Introduction” compared funeral rituals in Hindu, Vedic tradition with the Old Norse tradition and revealed great similarities.

​

In the Hindu examples as well as in the Old Norse, we see that different places and contexts may have been used for the remains that is left after cremation.

In the Hindu tradition, the ashes become a surrender to the waters of the sacred rivers.

​

In the Old Norse tradition, there are sacred places.

I quote Kaliff/Östigård:

“It is usually considered important to maintain the ritual ties between generations, and to reunite the deceased person with their ancestors.”

End of quote

​

For me, two things stand out clearly in this process. One is that the content of the book makes it clear that the comparisons between the Vedic, Hindu world of ideas can be compared with the Old Norse. It is a big geographical leap of thousands of kilometers. It is worth noting. How could a pervasive knowledge travel across time and space if it was not of significant importance?

​

But what also stands out as clear is the meaning of how this has happened, based on an understanding of the Indo-European idea and why it constituted such a strong connection in relational contexts; it does so in a geographical but also cultural sense, across time and space. We are talking about 5000 years ago and thousands of kilometers, which took only some hundred years to spread over continents, during the Bronze age. Still, it is maintained until the Viking age, more than a thousand years later.

It has obviously been important.

​

 “It is usually considered important to maintain the ritual ties between generations, and to reunite the deceased person with their ancestors.”

​

What does this mean? In my eyes, it is a clear act of respect for the subconscious. In the rituals we see how the culture of the dead must be passed on. Since they are dead, this cannot happen in any other form than the subconscious.

​

I quote Kaliff/Östigård:

"Many examples show that it is often of fundamental importance that the dead person is cremated in a well-defined ritual place; with special cosmological significance - a sacred place - but that the burned remains are not buried or left there. Often this is a special cremation place that is spatially separated from everyday activities, where the dead body is transported to be cremated.

 

The cremation itself is carried out there either by the family or relatives of the deceased, or by special ritual functionaries, specialized in this task. The transport of the body to the cremation place itself can then also have an important ritual function as a step in separating the dead from the everyday environment of the living.

 

The spatial transfer is a step in freeing the dead person from the old existence in the world of the living, in order to unite with the ancestors through the rituals.”

End of quote

​

This is a realistic picture of the primeval giant Ymir. He is devided into aspects of the heaven and earth and the cow Audumbla transforms.

​

An important aspect of how one thinks about the subconscious in the Indo-European tradition is the relationship to the human body and its different parts in relation to creation myths.

There is in every tradition an “Primal God”. This primal god is in the Nordic tradition Ymer. Ymer can be derived from Yama in the old Indo-European tradition.

​

In the myths, the primal god is cut up and thereby transformed into the earth and the world we live in, which consists of sea, mountains and vegetation.

​

I quote Kaliff/Östigård:

“That different elements in the cosmos are identical to the body parts of the sacrificed primal-being appears as a fundamental cosmological notion. It means that one entity is created from the matter in another, they constitute “all forms”, that is, alternative forms of each other.

​

For example, flesh and earth are considered to be of the same material substance and can therefore pass into each other. In the same way, bones, the harder parts are equated with the stones in the earth and with the mountains, while hair is associated with plants. Expressed differently, one can see, for example, flesh and earth as alternative forms in a continuous process, where one form is constantly transmuted into another.

​

Connected to this is a vertical division of the cosmos, also linked to the body of the original being. In Indian cosmology, there is thus a division into three levels: heaven, atmosphere and earth.

 

Heaven is then associated with the upper part of the body - the head, while the earth is connected to the feet and in other Indo-European traditions, usually to the flesh.

​

This is clear in Grimnismál and also in an old Russian variant of the story. In Old Russian, the word for body is Tèlo, derived from the Proto-Indo-European root Tel-, which stands for the surface of the body, as well as on the earth.

This can be compared to the Latin Tellus or Old Latin Talam, as well as the Old Russian t’lo, which also means earth. Just as bones are the harder substance inside the flesh of the body, stones are the harder equivalent inside the earth (Lincoln 1986 5ff).”

​

A little later:

“The transfer of the myths into various other traditions can in itself be considered as evidence of their great endurance. Through this identification of various phenomena in the cosmos as corresponding to different parts of the human body, according to Lincoln, a very important part of the creation mythology that was embraced by almost all peoples who spoke Indo-European languages ​​was formed (Lincoln 1986: 11-20).

​

Offerings in the form of dairy and agricultural products as well as animal sacrifices to the dead are also mentioned as an important part of the communication with the dead that becomes a clear expression of how one wants to convey a thought, power and direction through the ritual.”

End of quote

​

I would argue that this involves a care, a concern, that also includes what we today call the subconscious. It is done in a cultural act as a cultural transference. It would probably be considered superstition today, but I believe that such cultural acts matter, that we have this care for the living, the dead, and in the future also for those who will be born.

​

This is something we can learn from history. I want to say that the monotheistic rituals represented in the Christian church and in other contexts have “borrowed” cultural expressions from the Indo-European tradition, for example, the Communion.

​

I quote Kaliff/Östigård:

“The sacrifices were a way of maintaining communication between the living and the dead, or with deities who were imagined to have a special meaning in the context.”

End of quote

​

One can perhaps see divinities in this context as being principles, communication generators in the living moment when one bids farewell to the dead and finds a congruence with life here and now. I would think that the strong inherited traditions in these contexts have influenced a Christian perspective on the Communion.

​

How can we talk about “the subconscious” based on older tradition?

​

Common features in Indo-European tradition

​

It is interesting to see how the subconscious, or rather what in older traditions is called hidden inner reality, dream states or soul forces, is transformed in Indo-European tradition.

The subconscious is often seen as chaotic but creative – something that must be transformed through ritual, myth and symbol.

​

Transformation occurs through initiation, death and rebirth motifs.

Dreams, visions, ecstasy are ways to reach the subconscious and make it a source of wisdom, not just confusion.

​

In modern times we could say that Indo-European traditions worked with "the subconscious" through symbols, myths, rites and poetic language – rather than through introspection (self-reflection) in the psychological sense.

​

Some selections from different Indo-European traditions

Greek, Celtic and Nordic traditions

​

Greek tradition

​

Daimon and the shadow:

The Greeks had the idea of ​​“daimon”, an inner guiding force that could be both destructive and transformative. Philosophy, e.g. Plato, saw the soul's lower impulses as something to transform through rational insight and asceticism.

​

Mystery cults worked to transform the inner, unconscious fear of death through mythical experiences, symbolism and ritual.

​

The Myth of Heracles

​

Heracles as a symbol of the struggle of the self

In the Greek tradition, in the Archaic period, people were for a time obsessed with how to understand what we today call "the subconscious", in a way through time and over time for generations. They arrive at a concept:

Catharsis.

​

It is about how the subconscious can be understood by processing crises in the present.

Catharsis is a feeling of emotional purification and relief that is achieved by expressing or experiencing strong emotions, for example through art or theater, or by processing underlying trauma. It is about “healing”.

​

Aristotle used the concept of catharsis in the Poetics to describe the effect of tragedy on the audience, an emotional “purification” or relief by arousing strong emotions such as fear (phobos) and pity (eleos).

 

The myths that formed the basis of the tragedies are full of such moments.

​

Heracles

​

The myth of Heracles can be read as a dramatic allegory of man’s struggle with his own subconscious, and as a process that culminates in catharsis, the purification or clarification that is particularly formulated by Aristotle.

​

Heracles is the son of the god Zeus and the mortal Alcmene, a double descent that reflects man’s tension between the divine that could consist of ideals and an upward striving.

 

The other is earthly drives, that is, the body and its affects.

From the very beginning, he is pursued by Hera, who from a psychological perspective can be understood as the destructive force of the psyche – jealousy, anger, revenge. When Hera drives him to madness so that he kills his wife and children, it is a dramatic image of how the unconscious can break through and destroy conscious life.

​

Every work is a symbolic descent into the chaotic and threatening – and a return with new integrated strength. It is not just external heroic deeds, without internal transformation processes.

​

Heracles is stealing the Apples of the Hesperides.

The crucial thing is that Heracles is not a flawless hero. His greatness lies in the fact that he must atone for his crime. The tragic guilt is central. Just as in Greek tragedy, catharsis arises through the audience experiencing fear and pity.

​

When we observe Heracles, we can think that we fear the uncontrolled rage that can strike anyone and we feel pity for his suffering and penance.

This emotional movement leads to catharsis – a purification or clarity where the audience processes their own destructive impulses through the depiction of the myth.

Heracles eventually becomes immortal, he is accepted among the gods. Symbolically, this might mean that through suffering and work, he has integrated his completely fragmented being. The chaotic force has been transformed, through his effort and conscious awakening, into conscious strength.

​

The Heracles myth can therefore be read as catharsis arising both in the hero and in the viewer. The myth functions as a dramatic staging of the conflicts of inner life and could show that the path to reconciliation is not through denying the dark, but through facing it.

​

Collective rituals that open up to the subconscious

​

The symbolism of Dionysus

 

Theatre's connection to Dionysus

​

Philosophical interpretations

​

Dionysus was associated with wine, intoxication, dance and music – all states that take people out of the conscious control of everyday life.

In the Dionysian mysteries, the participants strove for ekstasis (“to stand outside oneself”) and enthousiasmos (“to become possessed/inspired by the god”).

 

These concepts correspond to experiences where the subconscious takes over and the rational boundaries of the self are blurred.

​

The Dionysian festivities often included nocturnal processions, wild dancing, masks and animal-imitating screams.

By wearing a mask or losing oneself in ecstasy, the individual's conscious identity could "dissolve" and deeper, archaic forces in man could emerge - something we would understand today as a contact with the subconscious.

​

Dionysus is a transboundary god: both male and female, both civilized and wild, both life-giving (the vine, fertility) and destructive (madness, dissolution). This duality reflects the ambivalence of the subconscious - both creative and chaotic forces.

​

He also represents rebirth, he is torn apart and resurrected in the myths, something that can be interpreted as psychological processes where man is transformed through contact with his hidden layers.

​

Thyrsos was in Greek and Roman mythology a staff made from the narthex bush. It was entwined with vines and ivy with a pine cone on top. The staff was associated with Dionysus/Bacchus and his companions, satyrs and maenads. It was a symbol of prosperity, fertility, desire and pleasure. Dionysus himself is depicted with such a staff, with which he could turn everything he touched into grapes.

 

A Maenad is a female worshiper of Dionysos.

Greek tragedy was born from the Dionysus cult. The theater became a collective arena where subconscious urges, conflicts and taboos could be staged in ritual forms.

 

The audience experienced catharsis - a purification by having their inner conflicts and feelings reflected and released.

Ancient thinkers such as Plato and Aristotle already noted how ecstasy, dreams and irrational impulses were part of the inner life of man.

​

Later psychological interpreters such as Freud and Jung often used Dionysus as a symbol of the forces in the psyche that cannot be controlled by reason.

​

In short, the cult of Dionysus was a way for the ancient Greeks to ritually acknowledge and deal with what we today call the subconscious: the dark, creative, irrational and transformative layers of man.

​

Celtic tradition

​

Arwen and inspiration

​

Cerridwen and the cauldron

​

The myth of Ceridwen and the concept of Arwen are not directly connected in the original Welsh mythology – but they can be linked thematically and linguistically. Arwen is actually a Welsh name that means roughly “noble woman” or “noble maiden”. It became particularly famous through the character Arwen in Tolkien’s works.

​

In Welsh tradition Ceridwen brews a magical potion in her cauldron to give wisdom to her ugly son Morfran.

The young boy Gwion is tasked with guarding the cauldron, but three drops of the potion splash onto his finger. When he licks them off, he gains all wisdom and insight.

 

Ceridwen chases him furiously, and they both transform through a series of animal forms. Finally, Ceridwen swallows him when he turns into a grain.

She becomes pregnant and later gives birth to the child who becomes the great bard Taliesin.

​

Taliesin

​

I think that here is an example of subconscious transformation in the myth. Gwion starts out as a simple servant, but when he gets the three drops, the whole process transforms into something else. He wakes up. Ceridwen doesn't like this. They both fight different battles in a transformation process that ends with Gwion finally being transformed into a grain that Ceridwen swallows.

 

This is where the great poet Taliesin was born.

The process could mean, from a perspective of the subconscious, that Gwion's consciousness is transformed, becomes higher. Ultimately, it comes out in a poetry that helps people understand transformation and consciousness in a new way. It is a development that might lead to ideas concerning how we process our daily consciousness into something that adds a greater perspective to life.

Here the myth of Ceridwen and Gwion has an important meaning regarding the Indo-European transformation of the subconscious in its culture.

​

 An example from Old Norse mythology: the god Kvasir

​

Through Kvasir comes inspiration and knowledge

The concept of “Asir” might represent thought and “Vanir”

might represent all biological fundaments of life. 

​

When it comes to the Nordic, I would like to mention the god Kvasir. He is related to both Bacchus and Dionysus in the Indo-European tradition.

​

The Asir and Vanir spit in the cauldron Odrörer together. What does this stand for?

The Vanir can be said to constitute the biological, the chemical in us humans that constitute a kinship with Nature and everything that lives around us.

The Asir can be said to constitute a “power of thought” and the spiritual consciousness that lives in us humans.

​

Here one can imagine that Kvasir becomes a foundation for the mixing of this. This mixing constitutes a myriad of energies that can be thought to include both the sharpness of thought, as well as the smallest of the chemical and biological; this makes me associate it with the subconscious.

​

The subconscious can be thought to consist of biological and chemical processes on an unimaginably small level, where quantum mechanics in the smallest of the universe takes place. Perhaps Kvasir here becomes a principle for an interaction?

​

The world is made up of matter. That is how far we understand life on Earth from a scientific perspective today. The explosion of quantum mechanics into the arena of understanding in the microcosm has changed our view of reality.

One can possibly think about how the subconscious comes into play here.

​

For me, the deity Kvasir represents a transformation in itself of a consciousness that extends far out in several directions. One direction is thought and our conscious self. Another is all the way into the biological foundation that we humans constitute.

​

For me, this means that the god Kvasir has an inherent transparency in the conscious and the subconscious. If the biological and chemical have an inherent interaction with “thought”, via the spit in the cauldron, then the subconscious must also be present.

​

 From a modern perspective it is interesting to hear physicist Brian Cox:

​

"What does it mean to live a Fragile and Finite Life in an Infinite and Eternal Universe?"

​

If anything, this question is about exploring. It may be obvious, but it still seems worth saying it again. At the heart of the Indo-European tradition is the concept of exploring your life in the context you live, as part of the larger reality you perceive, in the place you live, together with others, as something most important about life itself.

​

As if by chance this constitutes, with its inherent content, something that stands in strong contrast to the monotheistic tradition.

Well, my point here is that in some way this also has to do with the subconscious. What does it mean that research is demonstrably proving that we live in ​​an infinite number of universes, in a multiverse?  What does it mean that our history of a universe that is 13.8 billion years old is now being radically revised, in the look of the concept of not being the only universe; but this universe is just a part of, is a bubble within a complex multiverse? What does this mean to us?

​

In the small world, consisting of quantum physics, the concept of superposition is now being constantly proven. Our new quantum computers gather information via mathematical calculations we have never had access to; electrons have a binary contact over infinite distances in the universe.

 

Superposition also means that a particle can be in several places at the same time. That is what our quantum computers work on.

​

In the perspective of mind and cosmos: The small cosmos, which is made up of quantum mechanics, could be part of what we call the subconscious, in a connection between the subatomic to a macro perspective.

​

In modern research, people are also searching, now more than ever in view of technological development, for the underlying principles of the universe being a part of a multiverse.

It has to do with the concept of “The Inflationary multiverse”.

 

This goes back to the picture that was taken in the beginning of the 21 century of the inflation of the universe, about 380 000 years after the Big Bang. 

​

Scientists today have made up a hypothesis that claims that this inflation was just the end of a process, and that this process is something that is currently going on.

 

Through mathematical calculations this theory leads to the existence of a multiverse which our universe is just a little part of, a bubble.  

​

Politics and the subconscious today

​

In conclusion, I would like to take an example from politics:

When Trump says what he wants, we cannot know anything about what he wants. Our society has voted for one of the world's highest leaders who is not personally integrated. How could we miss such a big deal?

​

I would like to argue that a large part of it is due to politicians' ignorance of how people really act and have been acting. But you should also consider how people think. By that, I mean how politicians think and how those who vote for these politicians think.

 

Remember that Hitler was voted as leader in 1933.

In other words, we need to reflect on how we think.

 

This is where reflection comes in, which is the only way to have our “good subconscious” with us in thought and action, also when we vote.

​

I want to end again, with what was written on the temple of Apollo in Delphi:

​

"Know yourself, no exaggeration, overconfidence leads to decay".

​

Today we hear politicians saying that according to my book this means that we have the right to your land. The other part says the same thing. It is happening today.

​

If anything, this suggests that we must work on ourselves in the present, including the subconscious. We must dare to develop, see ourselves in a larger context, where society becomes a unified structure due to a work in the entities that we as individuals constitute.

Live well in this work!


Sources:

Bonnard: Grekisk Livsform

Kaliff/Östigård: Kremation och Kosmologi – En Komparativ Arkeologisk Introduktion

Brian Cox: Articles and TV programs 

Swedish Television, Axess TV: A program about sleep and death

Gibson: Grekisk Mytologi

Wikimedia Commons

Wikipedia

Proinsias Mac Cana: Celtic Mythology

DRA.png
bottom of page